Judge & Jury Badge
From Paragon Wiki Archive
Description
You defeated one of the signature "Rogues Gallery" characters in an Alignment or Morality mission earning yourself this badge.
How to Get
Defeat any character belonging to the Rogues Gallery enemy group during an Alignment or Morality mission.
Note
The Judge and Jury badge is awarded to characters of the hero and vigilante alignments. The same badge on villains and rogues is called Merciless.